Introduction: Not All Additives Are Created Equal
Food additives exist on a spectrum—from genuinely safe to genuinely dangerous. Understanding where each additive falls on the risk ladder helps you make informed choices without becoming paralyzed by food fear.
This guide organizes additives into five risk levels, from “generally safe” to “absolutely avoid.” Use this as your shopping reference.
The Risk Ladder Framework
text
TIER 5: ABSOLUTELY AVOID (Highest Risk)
│
TIER 4: LIMIT SEVERELY (High Risk)
│
TIER 3: LIMIT/CHOOSE ALTERNATIVES (Moderate Risk)
│
TIER 2: GENERALLY ACCEPTABLE (Low Risk)
│
TIER 1: MINIMAL CONCERN (Safest)
TIER 1: MINIMAL CONCERN (Safest Additives)
These additives have strong safety records and minimal health concerns.
✅ NATURAL GUMS
Examples: Xanthan gum, gum arabic, locust bean gum
What they do: Thicken and stabilize foods
Safety level: Excellent (minimal evidence of harm even at high doses)
Where found: Ice cream, salad dressings, plant-based milks, baked goods
Why it’s safe: Comes from natural plant sources; indigestible (passes through unchanged); long history of safe use
Recommendation: Generally fine; no need to avoid
✅ CITRIC ACID
What it does: Preservative and flavor enhancer; common in acidic foods
Safety level: Excellent
Where found: Beverages, jams, sauces, canned foods
Why it’s safe: Occurs naturally in citrus fruits; metabolized like natural citric acid
Recommendation: No concerns
✅ ASCORBIC ACID (VITAMIN C)
What it does: Preservative; prevents oxidation
Safety level: Excellent (actually beneficial)
Where found: Many processed foods; supplements
Why it’s safe: Same as vitamin C you’d get from oranges; your body needs it
Recommendation: Beneficial; look for this instead of synthetic preservatives
✅ TOCOPHEROLS (VITAMIN E)
What they do: Preservative; prevents fat rancidity
Safety level: Excellent (actually beneficial)
Where found: Oils, nuts, baked goods
Why it’s safe: Same as vitamin E from nuts and seeds; antioxidant
Recommendation: Beneficial; preferred preservative choice
✅ BETA-CAROTENE
What it does: Natural color and vitamin A source
Safety level: Excellent
Where found: Colored foods, margarine, some fortified products
Why it’s safe: Same as in carrots and sweet potatoes
Recommendation: Fine; often a sign of fortification with vitamin A
✅ CARMINE (COCHINEAL EXTRACT)
What it does: Natural red color from insects
Safety level: Good (though not vegan/vegetarian)
Where found: Some yogurts, beverages, candies
Why it’s safe: Natural source; long history of use; minimal allergic reactions
Note: If vegan/vegetarian, avoid; otherwise fine
✅ SALT
What it does: Preservative and flavor
Safety level: Good (in moderation)
Where found: Nearly all processed foods
Why it’s “safe”: Essential nutrient; concerns only arise with excessive intake (>5g daily)
Recommendation: Fine in products unless you’re monitoring sodium; check nutrition label for total daily sodium
✅ SUGAR (CANE, BEET, COCONUT)
What it does: Sweetener and preservative
Safety level: Good (in reasonable amounts)
Where found: Most processed foods
Why it’s “safe”: Natural source; metabolized normally
Concern: Excessive intake linked to obesity, diabetes, heart disease
Recommendation: Choose products with <5g added sugar per serving; sugar itself isn’t the problem, overconsumption is
TIER 2: GENERALLY ACCEPTABLE (Low Risk)
These additives have acceptable safety records but warrant some caution, especially for vulnerable populations.
⚠️ MODIFIED FOOD STARCH
What it does: Thickener and texture improver
Safety level: Generally safe; minor concerns
Where found: Gravies, sauces, processed foods, gluten-free products
Health concern: Some studies suggest modified food starch may affect gut bacteria; evidence mixed and inconclusive
Recommendation: Generally fine; if concerned about gut health, choose products with natural gums instead
⚠️ PECTIN
What it does: Natural thickener and gelling agent
Safety level: Good (naturally derived)
Where found: Jams, yogurt, beverages
Health concern: Minimal; some people report GI upset but rare
Recommendation: Fine; naturally derived from fruit
⚠️ GELATIN
What it does: Thickener and gelling agent
Safety level: Good
Where found: Desserts, gummies, supplements, yogurt
Note: Not vegetarian/vegan (from animal bones/skin)
Recommendation: Fine if animal products acceptable to you
⚠️ LECITHIN (SOY, SUNFLOWER, EGG)
What it does: Emulsifier and thickener
Safety level: Good (naturally derived)
Where found: Chocolate, baked goods, dressings
Health concern: Minimal; some concern about soy if not organic (GMO pesticide residues) but lecithin processing removes most proteins
Recommendation: Generally fine; choose sunflower or egg lecithin if concerned about GMO soy
⚠️ POTASSIUM SORBATE
What it does: Preservative (prevents mold/bacteria)
Safety level: Acceptable; some concerns
Where found: Baked goods, dressings, beverages, dried fruits
Health concern: Generally recognized as safe; some animal studies show potential reproductive concerns at very high doses; human evidence lacking
Recommendation: Fine in normal amounts; not ideal but acceptable
⚠️ CALCIUM PROPIONATE / SODIUM PROPIONATE
What they do: Preservative (prevents mold)
Safety level: Acceptable; emerging concerns
Where found: Bread, baked goods
Health concern: Animal studies suggest may increase hormones associated with diabetes and obesity; limited human evidence
Recommendation: Fine occasionally; if buying bread frequently, choose brands without it
⚠️ SODIUM PHOSPHATE / POTASSIUM PHOSPHATE
What they do: Emulsifier, buffer, preservative
Safety level: Acceptable; some concerns
Where found: Processed meats, cheese, baked goods, soft drinks
Health concern: High phosphate intake linked to bone/kidney problems in some studies; generally considered safe at current levels
Recommendation: Fine in moderation; watch total phosphate intake if you have kidney concerns
⚠️ FERRIC OXIDE (E172)
What it does: Iron oxide color additive
Safety level: Generally acceptable
Where found: Supplements, some colored foods
Health concern: Minimal; iron compound but not bioavailable (doesn’t get absorbed)
Recommendation: Fine
TIER 3: LIMIT/CHOOSE ALTERNATIVES (Moderate Risk)
These additives have concerning research or are linked to specific health problems in sensitive populations. Try to avoid or minimize.
🟡 CARRAGEENAN (E407)
What it does: Thickener and stabilizer
Safety level: Moderate concern
Where found: Ice cream, plant-based milks, yogurt, salad dressings, processed foods
Health concern:
Animal studies: Causes intestinal inflammation and ulceration
May damage gut lining and alter microbiota
Particularly problematic for people with IBS or digestive issues
Some concern about genotoxicity (DNA damage) but limited human evidence
Who should avoid: People with IBS, Crohn’s disease, or sensitive digestion
Recommendation: CHOOSE ALTERNATIVES when possible
Look for: Xanthan gum, gum arabic, locust bean gum instead
Especially for plant-based milks and ice cream
🟡 SULFITES (E220-E228)
What they do: Preservative (prevent browning and bacterial growth)
Safety level: Moderate concern for certain populations
Where found: Wine, beer, cider, dried fruits, baked goods, jams, canned vegetables
Health concern:
Aggravate asthma in 5-10% of asthmatics
Cause headaches, breathing problems, rashes in sensitive people
Allergic reactions possible
Generally safe for most people
Who should avoid: People with asthma, sulfite sensitivity, histamine intolerance
Recommendation: If asthmatic, check labels; otherwise acceptable
🟡 BENZOATES (SODIUM BENZOATE, POTASSIUM BENZOATE) (E210-E213)
What they do: Preservative (prevent mold and bacteria)
Safety level: Moderate concern
Where found: Acidic foods: fruit juice, soda, pickles, condiments, salad dressings
Health concern:
Converts to benzene (carcinogen) when combined with vitamin C
Increases hyperactivity in children (especially with artificial colors)
Generally safe at current levels for adults
Animal studies suggest reproductive concerns at high doses
Who should avoid: Children (especially with artificial colors); people concerned about cancer risk
Recommendation: MINIMIZE in children’s foods; acceptable for adults in moderation
🟡 SODIUM NITRATE / NITRITE (E249-E252)
What they do: Preservative and color additive in processed meats
Safety level: Moderate-High concern
Where found: Bacon, sausage, ham, hot dogs, deli meats, cured fish
Health concern:
Converted to carcinogenic N-nitrosamines in stomach
Linked to higher cancer risk (colon, stomach, pancreas)
Greater risk with processed meat consumption
Research: 50g processed meat/day increases colorectal cancer risk by 18%
Who should avoid: Everyone (but especially children and people with family cancer history)
Recommendation: MINIMIZE severely
Choose fresh meat when possible
If buying deli meat, select “uncured” or “nitrate-free” brands
Limit processed meat consumption to occasional
🟡 ARTIFICIAL SWEETENERS (E950-E959)
What they do: Sweetening without calories
Types: Aspartame (E951), Sucralose (E955), Saccharin (E954), Stevia (E960)
Safety level: Moderate concern (varies by type)
Where found: Diet sodas, sugar-free desserts, sports drinks, flavored water, yogurt, supplements
Health concern:
Aspartame (E951): Limited evidence linking to cancer; controversy continues
Sucralose (E955): Disrupts gut microbiota; alters glucose metabolism
Saccharin (E954): Bladder cancer concerns in animal studies (limited human evidence)
Stevia (E960): Generally safe; less concerning than synthetic sweeteners
All: May impair insulin sensitivity
All: May alter sweet taste preference (make you crave more sweets)
Who should avoid: Pregnant women (limited safety data); people with phenylketonuria (aspartame); children (developing brains)
Recommendation: MINIMIZE
Stevia or monk fruit preferred if sweetener needed
Best option: Reduce need for sweet tastes altogether
Limit to occasional use
🟡 MSG (MONOSODIUM GLUTAMATE) (E621)
What it does: Flavor enhancer; makes food taste more “savory”
Safety level: Moderate concern
Where found: Chips, instant noodles, soups, broths, sauces, processed meats, Asian foods
Health concern:
Animal studies: Obesity, metabolic dysfunction, cardiotoxicity, hepatotoxicity, neurotoxicity
Increased pain sensitivity
Hyperinsulinemia and high cholesterol
Important caveat: Most animal studies used mega-doses (25x+ normal intake)
Limited human clinical evidence at normal dietary levels
2023 consensus: Low doses generally safe; high doses + repeated exposure may be problematic
Who should avoid: People with MSG sensitivity (though “Chinese restaurant syndrome” evidence mixed); those concerned about metabolic health
Recommendation: MINIMIZE
Read labels; choose brands without MSG
Often hidden as “natural flavoring” or “flavor enhancer”
Occasional consumption acceptable; regular consumption concerning
🟡 ARTIFICIAL COLORS (FD&C COLORS)
What they do: Color foods attractively
Types: Red 40 (E129), Yellow 5 (E110), Yellow 6 (E110), Red 3 (E128), Blue 1 (E133)
Safety level: Moderate concern (especially for children)
Where found: Candy, beverages, baked goods, cereals, sports drinks, children’s foods
Health concern:
Linked to hyperactivity in children (especially in combination with preservatives)
Some (Red 3) linked to cancer in animal studies
Neurobehavioral effects
Children more vulnerable due to smaller body size
Limited concern for adults at current levels
Who should avoid: Children (especially under 12); people concerned about cancer risk; those with behavioral sensitivity
Recommendation: AVOID in children’s foods
Many major brands make color-free versions (especially for EU market)
For adults: occasional exposure acceptable but unnecessary
🟡 CARAMEL COLOR (CLASS IV)
What it does: Brown coloring in foods
Safety level: Moderate concern
Where found: Cola drinks, baked goods, sauces, beer
Health concern:
Some types (especially Class IV produced with ammonia) may contain carcinogenic compounds (4-methylimidazole)
EU limits stricter than US
Generally safe at current levels but unnecessary exposure
Recommendation: CHOOSE ALTERNATIVES
Not essential additive; many products available without it
Look for products colored with caramel syrup or other natural colors
TIER 4: LIMIT SEVERELY (High Risk)
These additives have significant health concerns documented in research. Try hard to avoid.
🔴 EMULSIFIERS LINKED TO CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE (E460-E468, E472b, E472c, E339)
Examples:
Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC, E460)
Methylcellulose (E461)
Other celluloses (E462-E468)
Lactic ester of monoglycerides (E472b)
Diglycerides (E472c)
Trisodium phosphate (E339)
What they do: Thickening agents; emulsifiers; improve texture and mixing
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Ice cream
Salad dressings
Yogurt and dairy products
Baked goods
Processed foods requiring thick texture
Plant-based foods
Health concern (2023 BMJ Study, 9.9 million participants):
E460-E468 (Celluloses): 5-7% increased cardiovascular disease risk
E472b: 6% increased CVD risk; 11% increased cerebrovascular disease risk
E472c: Linked to coronary heart disease
E339: 6% increased coronary heart disease risk
Mechanism: Disrupts beneficial gut bacteria; causes intestinal inflammation; triggers systemic inflammation
Recommendation: STRONGLY LIMIT
Check labels carefully
Choose products with natural gums (xanthan gum, gum arabic) instead
Avoid if you have cardiovascular risk factors
Especially important if consuming multiple products with these daily
🔴 HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP (HFCS)
What it is: Sweetener (50% fructose, 50% glucose)
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Soft drinks (obvious)
Candy and snacks (obvious)
Yogurt, granola bars, juice, bread, ketchup, BBQ sauce, salad dressings, marinades, pasta sauce, Asian sauces, canned soups, plant-based milks, iced tea, coffee drinks (deceptive)
Health concern (2025 research):
Liver damage: Hepatic fat accumulation in 15 days; NAFLD accelerating
Insulin resistance: Dose-dependent; 10-25% daily calories from HFCS causes measurable impairment
Inflammation: Increases CRP more than regular sugar
Metabolic dysfunction: Blood sugar, triglycerides, blood pressure issues
Kidney disease: Linked to kidney damage
Obesity: Doesn’t trigger satiety hormones; easier to overconsume
Future projection: 55% non-alcoholic fatty liver disease prevalence by 2040
Why worse than sugar: Fructose metabolized by liver (bypasses normal regulation); goes directly to fat storage; doesn’t trigger fullness signals
Recommendation: STRONGLY LIMIT or ELIMINATE
Read ingredient lists religiously
Avoid products with HFCS in first 3 ingredients
Choose cane sugar, stevia, or monk fruit instead
This is one ingredient worth spending extra money to avoid
🔴 ARTIFICIAL COLORS (Focus on RED 3/Red Dye No. 3)
Specifically: Red Dye No. 3 (Erythrosine)
What it does: Bright red food coloring
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN (especially concerning among all dyes)
Where found: Candy, frosting, beverages, some baked goods, maraschino cherries
Health concern:
Caused cancer and thyroid tumors in animal studies (since 1980s)
FDA acknowledged potential cancer risk
Linked to hyperactivity and behavioral problems in children
Already banned in cosmetics (1990) but still allowed in food
FDA announced intention to ban in 1990s but never acted (35 years later, still in use)
Recommendation: STRONGLY AVOID
This is especially important to avoid
Check labels for “FD&C Red No. 3” or “Red 3”
Completely unnecessary additive
Many alternatives available
🔴 POTASSIUM BROMATE (E924)
What it is: Flour improver; strengthens bread dough
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Packaged bread (soft heroes, sandwich loaves)
Frozen pizzas
Baked goods
Dumplings
~190+ US products
Health concern:
Suspected carcinogen (linked to kidney and thyroid tumors in animal studies since 1980s)
Recent research: Nervous system damage
FDA acknowledges risk but allows “safe” levels
Long delayed phase-out
Recommendation: STRONGLY AVOID
Check ingredient lists on bread
Buy from local bakeries or brands that specifically don’t use it
Banned in: EU, UK, Canada, China, India, Argentina, Brazil
California banned in 2023; FDA working on phase-out (voluntary)
🔴 TITANIUM DIOXIDE (E171)
What it is: Whitening agent; makes foods opaque/bright white
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Baked goods and bread
Candy and confectionery
Cheese
Some supplements
Often labeled “color added”
Health concern:
Banned EU 2022 (after reviewing thousands of studies)
Potential DNA damage (genotoxicity)
Animal studies suggest chromosomal damage possible
FDA hasn’t reached same conclusion but reviewing petition to ban
Unnecessary additive (foods don’t need to be white)
Recommendation: STRONGLY AVOID
Check labels for “titanium dioxide” or “color added”
EU products safer (already banned there)
Easy to avoid; just requires label-reading
🔴 PROPYLPARABEN (E217)
What it is: Preservative; extends shelf life
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Corn tortillas (especially packaged)
Baked desserts and cakes
Cake icing
~50+ US products
Health concern:
Hormone disruption (endocrine disruptor)
Linked to cancer risk
Reproductive toxicity concerns
EU banned since 2006 (safety couldn’t be proven)
Recommendation: STRONGLY AVOID
Check labels on packaged bread products
California will ban in 2027
Many products available without it
🔴 TRANS FATS / HYDROGENATED OILS
What they are: Oils artificially treated to be solid
Safety level: HIGH CONCERN
Where found:
Baked goods, crackers, microwave popcorn, margarine, fried foods
Note: FDA banned in 2018, but trace amounts can still appear
Health concern:
Increase heart disease risk significantly
Raise “bad” cholesterol (LDL)
Lower “good” cholesterol (HDL)
Increase inflammation
Increase diabetes risk
Recommendation: STRONGLY AVOID
Check labels for “partially hydrogenated” or “hydrogenated” oils
These are genuinely dangerous
TIER 5: ABSOLUTELY AVOID (Highest Risk)
These additives have serious health concerns. Actively work to eliminate them from your diet.
🔴🔴 AZODICARBONAMIDE (E927a)
What it is: Dough conditioner and whitening agent (like potassium bromate)
Safety level: CRITICAL CONCERN
Where found: Bread and baked goods (though less common than potassium bromate)
Health concern: Linked to cancer
Banned in: Europe, India, China
Status: Still legal in US
Recommendation: ABSOLUTELY AVOID
Check ingredient lists on packaged bread
Buy from bakeries instead
Summary Table: The Additive Risk Ladder at a Glance
TIER 1: MINIMAL CONCERN (Safe to Use Regularly)
✅ Xanthan gum, gum arabic
✅ Citric acid
✅ Ascorbic acid (Vitamin C)
✅ Tocopherols (Vitamin E)
✅ Beta-carotene
✅ Carmine (natural red color)
✅ Salt (in moderation)
✅ Sugar (in moderation)
TIER 2: GENERALLY ACCEPTABLE (Safe in Moderation)
⚠️ Modified food starch
⚠️ Pectin
⚠️ Gelatin
⚠️ Lecithin
⚠️ Potassium sorbate
⚠️ Calcium/sodium propionate
⚠️ Sodium/potassium phosphate
⚠️ Ferric oxide (E172)
TIER 3: LIMIT/CHOOSE ALTERNATIVES (Moderate Risk)
🟡 Carrageenan (E407) → Choose xanthan gum instead
🟡 Sulfites (E220-E228) → Avoid if asthmatic
🟡 Benzoates (E210-E213) → Limit in children’s foods
🟡 Sodium nitrate/nitrite → MINIMIZE; choose uncured meats
🟡 Artificial sweeteners → Choose stevia or reduce sweet taste need
🟡 MSG (E621) → MINIMIZE; read labels
🟡 Artificial colors (except Red 3) → AVOID in children’s foods
🟡 Caramel color (Class IV) → Choose alternatives when possible
TIER 4: LIMIT SEVERELY (High Risk)
🔴 Emulsifiers (E460-E468, E472b, E472c, E339) → Choose natural gums
🔴 High fructose corn syrup (HFCS) → STRONGLY MINIMIZE
🔴 Artificial colors (focus on Red 3) → STRONGLY AVOID
🔴 Potassium bromate (E924) → CHECK BREAD LABELS
🔴 Titanium dioxide (E171) → STRONGLY AVOID
🔴 Propylparaben (E217) → CHECK PACKAGED BREAD
🔴 Trans fats/hydrogenated oils → STRONGLY AVOID
TIER 5: ABSOLUTELY AVOID (Highest Risk)
🔴🔴 Azodicarbonamide (E927a) → CHECK BREAD LABELS
🔴🔴 (Most dangerous already listed in Tier 4)
Practical Shopping Application
In 30 Seconds: Quick Risk Assessment
When reading an ingredient list, ask:
Is there HFCS? → Put it back (Tier 4: High Risk)
Any emulsifiers (E460-E468, E472b, E472c, E339)? → Choose alternative (Tier 4: High Risk)
Potassium bromate, titanium dioxide, propylparaben? → Put it back (Tier 4-5: High Risk)
Artificial colors (Red 3, etc.)? → Put it back if buying for children (Tier 4: High Risk)
Nitrates/nitrites in processed meat? → Choose uncured or skip (Tier 3-4: Moderate-High Risk)
MSG or “natural flavoring”? → Check if concerning to you (Tier 3: Moderate Risk)
Ingredient list 5-10 items or 20+? → Shorter is better (fewer additives overall)
If it passes these checks → Probably acceptable.
The Real-World Strategy
Perfect is the enemy of good. You don’t need to eliminate every Tier 3 additive immediately.
Phase 1: ELIMINATE (First Priority)
Focus on cutting out:
HFCS
Potassium bromate, titanium dioxide, propylparaben (check bread)
Artificial colors (especially Red 3)
Trans fats/hydrogenated oils
Nitrates/nitrites in processed meats
This eliminates 80% of the serious health risk.
Phase 2: REDUCE (Second Priority)
Once Phase 1 established, then minimize:
Emulsifiers (choose natural gums)
Sodium nitrate/nitrite (choose uncured)
Artificial sweeteners (choose stevia or reduce)
MSG (choose brands without it)
Phase 3: OPTIMIZE (Final Priority)
Fine-tune remaining choices:
Choose Tier 1 & 2 additives when alternatives available
Understand which Tier 3 additives concern you personally
Focus on whole foods overall
Important Perspective
Regulation Differences (Why This Matters)
EU: “Precautionary principle” – prove safe BEFORE approval
US: “Prove it’s harmful” – manufacturers can use additives, FDA acts when harm proven
Result: Many Tier 4-5 additives banned in EU are still legal in US.
2025 Reform: RFK Jr. pushing for FDA alignment with EU standards; major food companies already reformulating.
Resources for Going Deeper
Check Before Buying:
Print this ladder; carry while shopping
Use your phone camera to photograph labels
Download grocery store app (many show ingredients)
Verify Additives:
EFSA database (EU approved additives; very strict)
FDA food additives list (US approved; less strict)
Environmental Working Group (EWG) food additives guide
2025 Reform Information:
“Make America Healthy Again” initiative updates
State-level bans (California, New York)
Food company reformulation announcements
The Bottom Line
The Additives Risk Ladder gives you a simple framework: Know which tier each additive falls into, focus on eliminating Tiers 4-5 first, then gradually reduce Tier 3 exposure.
You don’t need to be perfect. But understanding the hierarchy helps you:
Spend your “worry budget” on the most concerning additives
Make meaningful health improvements
Avoid paralysis from trying to avoid everything
Start with Phase 1 (eliminate Tiers 4-5). You’ll see real health benefits immediately.
This risk ladder is part of Food Reality Check’s mission to help consumers make informed choices based on scientific evidence, not food fear. Last updated: December 2025